left a list of related proposals here
describedeflorationaccepted
@Rayona @cyber fucker
> Defloration is specifically the hymen breaking and bleeding not female virginity
> also, a woman can be a virgin, and not have a hymen. to conflate defloration with a female losing virginity is nonsensical
- there's a debate whether defloration should be for hymen breaking, or for the loss of female virginity. I honestly think this is wasted effort since we can just have separate tags for both [hymen rupture] & [female virginity loss]. I would also abandon [defloration] as a tag name to avoid any confusion. I think that most [defloration] is being used as [hymen rupture], too, but it's impossible to know with 38k galleries. I discuss this more in the link above
@cyber fucker
> but many works also use virginity to mean female virginity
- I actually don't think this is true. There are #38000|Saru ni Onanie|254 [defloration] galleries, and I think it's reasonable to assume that
most of them include a [female virgin]. If you were correct that [virginity] includes [female virgins], then we should expect much more galleries in [virginity] given the size of [defloration]
> this especially true in the world of doujins, where a woman could magically regain a hymen, despite not being a virgin
- you would have a point if [virginity] was being used for both male & female virgins. However, most signs point to the fact that its not, and is in fact being used primarily for [male virgins]. It is entirely plausible to sort the 3000* [virginity] galleries that aren't necessarily [male virgins]
*I got 3000 by searching [defloration] + [virginity]. Again, this assumes that most [defloration] involves [female virgins]. Galleries containing both a male virgin and female virgin are included in this query, so the number of [virginity] galleries involving a [male virgin] is even higher; we would have to sort out far less than 3000 galleries
but many works also use virginity to mean female virginity, especially when hymen breaking isn't physically visible. also, a woman can be a virgin, and not have a hymen. to conflate defloration with a female losing virginity is nonsensical. this especially true in the world of doujins, where a woman could magically regain a hymen, despite not being a virgin. i staunchly disagree with this renaming.