Rename: shielder → mash kyrielight

rename held 157d ago

character shielder 1.8k character mash kyrielight

note The shielder tag is useless. It's her class not her name and nobody ever calls her that. Same for the combo mash/shielder doujins. They should all be under one mash category.

reviewHeld for an admin

ranchdong Pending backend changes

62 Comments

The "spoilers" argument doesn't even work here, you literally find out that Mash is a Shielder during the tutorial. What would actually be a spoiler you only find out during Camelot, so no reason to not just use Mash here.

Saber = Artoria, Nero, etc. Rider = Medusa, Alexander, etc. Caster = Medea, Tamamo, etc. The list goes on and on and on and on... Very confusing indeed @darksilence1. As much as I'd like to put in suggestions for the f/go franchise, we have limits on the number of suggestions to make, not to mention the growing backlog our lovely mods have to sift through.

@HRInsane honestly true. Galahad simply existing makes the tag even more useless and potentially confusing.

"she's the one and only relevant servant with that tag" just wait till Galahad drops and we get some doujin of him

That was a byproduct of a different time in the franchise. Back when they actually gave a fuck about keep servant true names a secret. Dosent really apply to FGO. Case in point you never see Takeru tagged as samurai remnant Saber. The fsn cast are the OGs. They get a pass.

She is the only shielder but the tags not relevant. Shielders her class not her name. It would only be relevant if Mash ever got another class (which is probably never happening) for the sake of distinction. This is FGO not fsn. Classes aren't names.

shielder-mash-kyrielight is perfect

@darksilence1 rider is extra confusing when there's 2 different characters I've seen marked by the same tag. The one from fate zero and the one from fsn.

@Animefan: Sounds good! Updooted

Characters like Saber and Rider are very confusing.

I'm definitely aiming to change that one to just mash kyrielight also after this one gets approved. Mash tags in doujins have been a mess for years.

Please also take this tag into consideration: https://nhentai.net/character/shielder-mash-kyrielight/

1 2

Post a comment

62 Comments