@Sinfulhavoc6 Thank you for moving away from [reverse rape] > [reverse rape] gets renamed to [raped male] for specifically victim characters with a male body-type [...] introduce as many perpetrator tags as needed - the first one is a victim tag, the next one is a perpetrator tag. Perhaps that was an accident, but that introduces a lot more tags than my suggestion. I should be clear that mine only considers male and female perpetrator & victim combinations. So: rape = all types of rape male-on-female = "regular" rape female-on-male = "reverse" rape male-on-male = yaoi rape female-on-female = yuri rape Subsets don't need to add up to the superset so things like tentacle-on-female or goblin-on-male are ignored. They're part of [rape], but don't need their own subtag imo Also, my issue with having separate perp & victim tags is that combining them wouldn't necessarily return what the query wants. I give an example/explanation in the [female rapist] link I gave below

@fuckriri1234 Fine. How about this as a proposal? [rape] stays as an all-encompassing tag for all types of rape. [reverse rape] gets renamed to [raped male] for specifically victim characters with a male body-type including any animals, monsters, etc. (Dickgirls would be excluded since they tend to have more of a female body-type) Introduce [raped female] for specifically victim characters with a female body-type including animals, dickgirls, etc. Introduce as many perpetrator tags as needed. [female rapist], [male rapist], [dickgirl rapist], [animal rapist], etc. This way all stories with [rape] still say accurate, [reverse rape] gets a slight change that wouldn’t change any current stories, and having dedicated “perpetrator” tags would require much less tags compared to having every combo of “perp on victim” Anyone looking for any specific combo can do so in conjunction with [dickgirl], [yuri], [bestiality], etc. while still be able to blacklist any “unwanted players”

@Sinfulhavoc6 tentacles raping someone is just rape. I said in the link below my proposal only considers human sexes (male and female) create tag female rapist +5 And your idea to "keep it simple" isn't really simple because [rape] is not being used as a "female is assaulted." As shown with the [males only] query, there are at least 3000 galleries that don't fit that definition Not to mention, your definition doesn't allow for non-human assault which I hope even you can agree is rape (i.e. a dog getting raped or smth) There is also demand for both perpetrator and victim tags. Mine just uses rape as the superset, and creates four subsets for a total of five tags. I don't think that's an absurd amount especially considering threesomes have 10 subtags, and there are proposals for gendered foursomes which would have 15 subtags. A total of five tags pales in comparison while addressing a demand that is clearly present

@fuckriri1234 So how would you handle stories where a character gets assaulted by a plant monster, a mass of fleshy tentacles, or a mechanical robot? Add more subcategories? Rename the (reverse rape tag) to whatever, but I believe keeping it simple with the two tags (rape and reverse rape) to describe only the victim would be more intuitive as opposed to creating 5+ subcategories for every variation of “perpetrator on victim”.

@Sinfulhavoc6 no it's not, rape is rape: when a non-consenting partner gets assaulted. could be male, female, could even be a non-human alien. that's why 3030 galleries with [males only] also have the [rape] tag [reverse rape] is such a dumb term lol just call it [female-on-male rape] or [female raping male] like these two do and be done with it create tag male raping male +14 create tag female raping female +15

Rape is when a FEMALE character gets assaulted Reverse rape is when a MALE character gets assaulted