describe 65d ago
Tag description Flat is justice!
note Engulfs the whole community thinking and approval
staff Invalid description, not being updated by sugesstor. Please open a new suggestion
ranchdong ranchdong

Post a comment

Comments are closed on this suggestion.

43 Comments

swiftyooh
swiftyooh
Thank god this description was rejected. Like I said before small does not equal flat.
fuckriri1234
fuckriri1234
#F1ZK and that's the issue. I think flat and small is easily differentiated, but that midpoint is where things get fuzzy
fuckriri1234
fuckriri1234
here's a better display of flat chest
F1ZK
F1ZK
Great examples and I can see the point, honestly for me I just see it as the same thing BUT if we are going to be specific I guess it is two different thing in tags wisely. I get it and yeah I guess it is different
fuckriri1234
fuckriri1234
@F1ZK just look at the thumbnails (tw loli) small breasts flat chest somewhere in between; tiny breasts
F1ZK
F1ZK
Seems like people sees it different to actual flat breast to small breast, hmmm I can't seem to comprehend it as I see it as the same thing but maybe an example would be nice to have
F1ZK
F1ZK
Small or flat is the same because both correlates that they have small breast. You might be thinking of medium size as small and flat as.. well flat. Both are small and flat.
letsreallythinkaboutit
letsreallythinkaboutit
There's a difference between small and flat breasts that I think this refuses to acknowledge??? they should be their own two tags
ranchdong
ranchdong
I might start to revoke suggestions that are not in an acceptable state and not being maintained / edited by the owner as a policy going forward. I hesitate only because it makes things harder to communicate for y'all but keeps taxonomy moving and less stagnant as a whole.
fuckriri1234
fuckriri1234
@Aelter mb i must've misread it. I really like the order you proposed (stored in [1/3]). my only issue is that @Osamu09 who proposed "tiny chest" seems to define it as anything less than small (flat and "perky" both; if I'm wrong my bad).. i also think it's a little weird how the breast sizes all take the form [x breasts] like small breasts, large breasts, etc. and then we just have [flat chest] lol btw my old account got restricted (didn't even know was possible) cus i was copy/pasting this series' order across galleries
Aelter
Aelter
@Fuckriri: My own suggestion was actually ”Breast size. Each breast range from just above flat, up to a palmful.” meaning all breasts where the size is ANYWHERE between pettanko to palmful. So your example would fit well there. Per your comment ”Not entirely a palmful, but not flat either.” @Osamu: I’ve had sex with at least two women with flat chests. I think it helps to remember that ’flat’ is what we perceive with our eyes (and IRL our hands). It doesn’t mean that there’s just a ribcage under the skin. About the ’gigantic breast’ thing: I can see a lot of people having your view. If I am in the minority I’ll not be stubborn. I am perhaps older than most people here, and therefor more influenced by older terminology (i.e. ’bakunyuu’) than others. (Your example I would classify as ’gigantic breasts’.) Sidenote, @Fuckriri, where did you come from dog?? Registered a couple weeks ago and instantly started commenting on everything?! Not that I mind, I like your discussion!
swiftyooh
swiftyooh
@Aelter has the right idea. Small does not equal flat.
fuckriri1234
fuckriri1234
@Osamu09 flat chest isn't really saying that no tit fat exists, just that it's in such a small amount that the chest itself appears flat and tbh is it relevant to bring that up in a hentai site? i dont think anyone that sees "flat chest" is going to think, "ackshuallyyy, that's not realistic because all tits have fat, so it is impossible to have a flat chest" I get that there's a middle ground between flat and small (I refer to as "perky"), but defining that middle ground in an objective manner is pretty difficult. And calling it "tiny breasts" wouldn't be the best idea either because, as you said, tiny seems to include flat chest. no need to double up
Osamu09
Osamu09
@Aelter I was actually under the impression that "gigantic breasts" would fall under "hyper". It does seem like some people think of "gigantic breasts" as just a larger size of "huge breasts", like for example , it only had "huge breasts" when it was uploaded but they added the "gigantic breasts". But to me it would seem pointless to make such a distinction @fuckriri1234 my "tiny breasts" tag is actually supposed to be "flat chest", I just chose a different name, but that also means I left some margin of errors. Which makes sense because as I explained on the other suggestions, there's no such a thing as being flat, every female has breast tissue/fat, it's just the amount that varies and depending on other factors such as breasts shape they can be more or less noticeable
fuckriri1234
fuckriri1234
@Aelter I agree with your system from [3] except there may be a nirvana right between flat and small. Something like the thumbnail on Not entirely a palmful, but not flat either. Tbh do we need it? probably not, it just convolutes the tag pool and makes tagging harder for those not in the know. But yeah felt like pointing it out. Completely fine with small = anything larger than flat left more thoughts here create tag perky breasts -2
Aelter
Aelter
[1/3] My opinion: I downvoted this describe suggestion long ago because it's awful; but since it's the most upvoted of all the breast size tags, I'll provide some helpful links to all the good people here trying to create a proper system. FLAT CHEST create tag flat chest +32 TINY BREASTS create tag tiny breasts +29 SMALL BREASTS (You Are Here) MEDIUM BREASTS create tag medium breasts +25 BIG BREASTS describe big breasts +10 HUGE BREASTS describe huge breasts accepted GIGANTIC BREASTS describe gigantic breasts +69 For breasts that are impossibly big, I would suggest a 'hyper breasts' tag, or just my own create tag hyper +54
Aelter
Aelter
[2/3] I also think we'd be better off adapting Danbooru's size system, rather than eHentai's. DANBOORU flat chest — A female character with a completely flat chest, that is, no breasts whatsoever small breasts (b.) — About a palmful in size. In real-world sizes, this can run from just over AA cup to just under C cup medium b. — Each breast is larger than a palmful, but smaller than the character's face large b. — Around/more than the same volume as a sphere with the same diameter as the character's face, but smaller than their head huge b. — As large as/larger than the character's head but less than twice the size of their head gigantic b. — More than twice the size of the head EHENTAI small b. — Must be small enough to reasonably call the girl "flat" big b. — Generally large breasts huge b. — Abnormally large breasts. Must be at least double the size of the owner's head gigantic b. — Impossibly large breasts. Must be equal to or greater in size than the rest of the person's body
Aelter
Aelter
[3/3] If you want to know about Japanese terms like 'pettanko' and 'bakunyuu' (what most sites used way back), check out japanesewithanime.com and their "Breast Sizes" article. Finally, my own suggestions: flat chest — Breast size. A female character has a completely flat chest. Aka. 'flat-chested', 'pettanko', 'washboard chest' small breasts — Breast size. Each breast range from just above flat, up to a palmful. medium breasts — Breast size. Each breast range from a palmful to the owner's face diameter. big breasts — Breast size. Each breast sits within the diameter of the owner's face to their head. huge breasts — Breast size. Each breast is larger than the owner's head but still look realistically plausible. gigantic breasts — Breast size. Too large to be seen on a real life woman (disregarding 'macromastia') but still believable on a manga character. hyper breasts — Breast size. Ridiculously big. Can be as voluminous as a full-grown woman, or as a house, or even larger.
zurui san
zurui san
It should be average breast, wait do we have average breast tag...?! Damn it...!!! MEDIUM IS PREMIUM...!!!
Wholesome_only_pls
Wholesome_only_pls
Yeah I agree with the one below me. Since flat is obviously flat like those memes where they say they're a chopping board. So in that case "tiny breast" Should be in the flat is justice. Because even with small breast you could technically still squeeze them with the hands. The one example, I could think of that has small breast but is usually joked about "Being flat" (I could be wrong/misremembering this so you can correct me if I'm wrong.) Is Kaguya Shinomiya from Love is War. She has small breast but you can literally see it being squeezed by Miyuki Shirogane. Even if it's not a full on squeeze, as long as you can almost squeeze it, I think it's not flat is justice but just being small.
Osamu09
Osamu09
@ranchdong Female character with a below average size of breasts. They should be at least small enough that an average man's hands can fit them entirely. But they shouldn't be so small that their shape and curve is barely noticeable even when naked, for those cases use the "tiny breasts" tag
Ilya Repin
Ilya Repin
"big tits may fill your hands, but small tits will fill your hearth" confusius.
ranchdong
ranchdong
Actually i missed a few there are also: gigantic breasts and huge breasts tags too
ranchdong
ranchdong
Sadly, not enough here guys. We need some level of detail or substance and not just the meme. and I'm not opposed to accepting tiny and flat as well but we need to establish some level of guidelines currently the proposed landscape looks like this: big breasts, small breasts, tiny breasts, flat chest. I feel like if we can equate these to consistent rules and maybe add medium? we might be onto something.
DDnhen
DDnhen
small isn't flat. if there's a tiny breasts or flat chest tag then the description could work with that.
Osamu09
Osamu09
since many people seem to have missed it, create tag tiny breasts +29 let's be real, "small breasts" is very often used for breasts that are not flat at all
rizkid1412
rizkid1412
Small breasts and loli shouldn't be mixed together unless there's two different girls. Small breasts is when non loli have small breasts
GGMrCrow
GGMrCrow
definitely need a separate tag for small breasts and flat chest
Ash5O5
Ash5O5
I like all breasts size, they are cute But due to the porn industry bigger is better is misconception All breasts are good even small one~
vagooo
vagooo
huh, so they got rid of the pettanko [ぺったんこ] tag at some point pre-comm taxonomy. I do think 'flat-chested' is maybe diff than just small breasts?
Lapis_
Lapis_
not a bad idea, just needs to be slightly refined
aaa1e2r3
aaa1e2r3
Max A Cup? B Cup?
sexypistal293
sexypistal293
Need more technical definition under the tag. Do keep the punchline though!
40-sai archwizard
40-sai archwizard
What cup size are we talking about here to be tagged as small? The required size is needed to be added for the description.
CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY
CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY
The character has a small breast
Pornupine
Pornupine
"Flat is justice" is funny, although I think as a definition it's a bit thin. This tag in particular is tricky. It's probably worth having a bigger discussion, but that's hard to do in just the comment section. Some things worth considering: Is "flat" the minimum or below the threshold for the "small breasts" tag"? If flat is the minimum then what should be the upper limit? If part of the intention behind the tag is to help distinguish small breasts from loli content, then the definition needs to explicitly state their exclusion.
dzeroes
dzeroes
Medium is Premium
AdjustedJunk
AdjustedJunk
Honestly, with hentai, I'd use this tag with any works containing women of normal/average proportions, and not the giant watermellon-titted bimbos that are the norm. I would even suggest we have a separate "Flat" tag as well.
sylvie333
sylvie333
Keep small breasts, it's important that it is seperate from lolicon. Lolicon refers to characters that are underage while small breasts is just a body type that is honestly common amongst adult women, especially asian
Afastado
Afastado
I don't think we need to put small breasts with lolicon tag. Some people don't wanna see lolis when searching for small breasts, but I'm seeing a lot of people upvoting this on loli hentai. Maybe write something about this on the tag description?
muschi26
muschi26
In my opinion, small breasts should be for small but present breasts, not outright flat chests. It's used that way a lot at present, and I believe a distinction should be made.
vernogato
vernogato
yes as for size limit i believe if the nipple raises above where her breast starts by more than 1.7006 inches then it cannot be considered small breasts. someone get me a ruler!
Rhoik
Rhoik
Might need a bit more concrete/technical stuff, like the size limit for this tag yk. I agree tho