Back to suggestions
create 159d ago
tag dirty raw
Tag description Works that doesn't do one of the three cleaning tasks will count as dirty raw: 1. Cropping borders & canvas (scanner glass margins, adjacent page bleed, and yellowing pape edges) 2. Modify lighting (pure white backgrounds and solid black ink lines, or clear paper tint if that is color pages) 3. Wipe down dusting (no dust particles/speckles) Even if a work contains only 1 dirty page, it should be treated as dirty raw.
note I found a few works like this: https://nhentai.net/g/534192 . And I think we need to have a way to filter them out in case somebody don't to read it. Or some good guys willingly clean it up. They know what to look for.

Post a comment

or to post a comment.

7 Comments

Iamme00
Iamme00
Descriptions Short and factual. One or two sentences Put the full description in the notes, Tag Descriptions should be short
h2016
h2016
`raw flaws` sound good. It feels less offensive and more correct on the meaning.
40-sai archwizard
40-sai archwizard
Upvoting this and your other suggestion for scanlators' sake. And how would you like 'raw flaws' as an alternate tag name?
h2016
h2016
I honestly open for name suggestion. On my side, I use this keyword in my group to talk about any scan coming directly from scan machine without cleaning up so I thought it could be meaningful to other. But if you know other terms, please share it with us. It could help the staffs to make better decision.
Osamu09
Osamu09
I don't necessarily like "dirty raw" as a name, but your idea is actually solid. I just searched "raws" and I found this other example where the pages aren't cropped correctly
h2016
h2016
Change description: > A title is dirty raw even if a single page fails to have its borders cropped, lighting optimized, or foreign objects (dust, hair) removed.