@Zedratuguir2 There's nothing magical or supernatural about your example - remove that time travel bit and you're left with just a person getting thrown into a prehistoric uncivilized society. IMO for the intended context of this tag proposal your example isn't going to cut it, just like I would label Dr. Stone doujinshi as sci-fi rather than fantasy. It's a nice read though, thanks.

I'm honestly "racking my brain" if this one #154114 | Kigenzen 10000 Nen no Ota | The Otaku i… | 23,843 classifies as a "Fantasy". What do you people think?

@Rockman x 2nd When most people think about fantasy, Dungeons and Dragons is usually what comes to mind. If a story takes place in a medieval or ancient setting and includes magical elements or mythical creatures, that’s what most people consider fantasy. idk how useful this tag would be. Like, the main reason I would use this tag is to find doujins with hot mythical creatures like orcs, elves or onis, and I can already do that by simply searching those tags. But if the tag mainly focuses on the setting rather than on the creatures, then it will leave out works that include these mythical creatures but in a setting that isn't medieval or ancient like #635317 | Otonari-san no Moto Sword Master Elf!!… | 10,881 and idk if that would be a desired outcome.

if you wanna be pedantic, in meta, all pieces of porn with 2 people is ntr because youre not the one fucking the girl. it is still a useful category even if the definition isnt rigid

You're all smart. You guys can differentiate between fantastical fantasy based on tropes of magics and dragons with daydream fantasy which encompasses all of fiction

for all intents and purpose, every single work ever written is a piece of fantasy. if you want something, it should be clearer than just a single "fantasy" tag you want a generic RPG fantasy world? you want a lolicon story? you want a NTR story? you want to fuck a dragon? you want to be raped? you want Rance or Rias to have sex with you? you want a doting lover who actually loves you and will treat you just how you wanted? all that is fantasy. modern-day fantasy, medieval fantasy, RPG fantasy or futuristic fantasy or whatever, be clearer. don't have a generic fantasy tag and expect everyone to have the same idea of fantasy as you

this defo should be split into multiple tags. here's my suggestion: isekai adventurer fantasy sci-fi (shortened for science fantasy - not what you think, but you get the gist) chosen one npc/background chara medieval fantasy antiquity fantasy and so on

If we're talking about the broader definition of fantasy then about 99.9% of the uploads here will fall under that category because they're fiction based on the artists' fantasies duh, only those based on real life will be the exception. So I already suggested narrowing it down to what I said on my previous comment; any subtags after that can be posted on another proposal instead.

damn good points. i was assuming people will have the same expectation as me of what kind of fantasy when they see the fantasy tag. more reason to update the description

agree with @lord411 especially since fantasy can be misunderstood in a myriad of other ways: hallucinations, flashbacks, visions, etc. instead of the genre of media

Yes I need this

@octrice's stocking "fantasy" has hundreds if not thousand subgenres, and even in hentai it can get ridiculously broad and pointless. a hypnosis story in a modern school is still "fantasy" just because of magic hypnosis, and i doubt that's the goal of this tag. so it is important to be more specific

@lord411 I don't think we need to be that specific because fantasy tag will include any subgenres or relevant settings/themes to it. I'll use group tag as an example for this, because it covered tags involving multiple person (ffm,mmf,harem)

It needs to be more specific if it's about a specific type of fantasy. Like "european fantasy" or "medieval fantasy"

How is this not a tag yet.

I actually like this one, I rarely find anything involving fantasy

We NEED this tag, it's hard to find just fantasy elements.

How about we adapt from the wiki definition? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fantasy "Fantasy is a genre of speculative fiction that involves supernatural or magical elements, often including completely imaginary realms and creatures." I'd rewrite this as "Fantasy in hentai is a genre that has supernatural or magical elements outside the realm of real life possibilities." BTW, there's create tag sci-fi +14 for robot maids and the like that are more grounded in science.

nice tag to have and i think OP should update the description just like the user before me said

And shouldn't the description be more understandable with its scopes and the description u wrote here should be note for this tag. U can edit it.

Just a question what is the scope of this tag which doijin is included and which is not. I understand Isekai and adventure World settings but what about magic, monster, demon, etc.

This is basically my only problem here right now, need a fantasy tag definitely

frrrr, I love fantasy themed doujins but it's just really hard to find without any tags that related to it.

This HAS TO become a tag, it's just simple and clear to follow, it isn't vague at all, it's either a fantasy or it's not. Please make this a tag.

Hope this got accepted

i signed up just to suggest this, so frustrating to not have this tag its so weird like i cant think of any valid reason for this tag to not have existed like 10 years ago

Yesh sadly i cant edit the description :'> but from the comment and the accepted tag the description Will be change by the admin OvO

useful tag but prolly needs better description

Personally, I think I'd keep this tag, but wouldn't include isekai in it.

@YuriLover31 I know right! I really love the setting when it come to fantasy world but its kinda hard to find it TwT @Osamu09 i see! OH IM AGREE, setting is kinda best like school setting, fantasy setting, office setting or etc, i know its like asking too much, but that is one of an awesome idea

@kuro60, doesn't matter. Admins are gonna change the description themselves. Feel free to post one in the comments and they might consider using that. Also I've said this in a few other suggestions, but I think that, if possible, they should make a separate category for "setting", just like there's "parodies" and "characters"

Everytime I type in fantasy, nothing really comes up besides final fantasy or granblue fantasy i feel like it's a huge missed opportunity

Dang.... I cannot make new post

OOOH SORRY, my first time using this, im gonna repost this Thank you odysseus!

That’s a good idea, but i think that you might have mixed up the tag description with the note option. I recommend you repost it. I think you can leave the description empty and just let someone else to fill it in for you if you don’t feel like filling it in.

I'm very excited seeing others suggest genre tags too! Here's hoping they get accepted.